EMR
Gem factors

Value factors by gemstone

What drives the price of each precious stone — colour, clarity, cut, size, treatments and origin — with emerald first.

01 / General value factors
01

Color: hue, tone and saturation

Color is judged on three components: hue (the basic color, e.g. bluish green), tone (how light or dark) and saturation (how free the color is of gray or brown). Pure, vivid colors in a medium to medium-dark tone usually command the highest prices, while very pale or near-black stones are worth far less. Look for even color without visible zoning, and view the stone face-up against both white and dark backgrounds.

02

Lighting when judging color

Light changes how a gem looks: incandescent bulbs add red and warmth, many fluorescent tubes strengthen blue, and shade or an overcast sky adds blue and gray. Grade color under neutral, daylight-equivalent light, then check the stone under the lighting where it will actually be worn. Color-change gems such as alexandrite must be seen under both daylight and incandescent light. Rest your eyes now and then, since staring at one color distorts perception.

03

Clarity

Clarity is the degree to which a stone is free of inclusions (internal features) and blemishes (surface marks). Expectations depend on the species: emerald, ruby and red tourmaline are normally included, while aquamarine, topaz and tanzanite are usually eye-clean. Judge first with the naked eye, then with a 10x loupe under overhead light; cracks on the table and deep fractures that threaten durability hurt value most. Light-colored stones reveal inclusions more readily than dark ones.

04

Transparency

Transparency describes how freely light passes through a gem, from transparent through translucent to opaque. It is often as important as color: a well-colored emerald that is only translucent can be worth several times less than a transparent one. Clouds, dense inclusions and fine particles make a stone look hazy, milky or 'sleepy'. For translucent gems such as jade, greater translucency still means greater value.

05

Cut, proportions and life

A good cut brings out color and brilliance. Face-up, look for a window (a pale, see-through area in the center) and for excessive extinction (dark, lifeless zones). In profile, colored stones are typically 60–80% as deep as they are wide: overly deep stones look small and make you pay for excess weight, while very shallow ones show windows and may be fragile. Also check symmetry, girdle thickness and bulging pavilions, and above all the stone's overall 'life' — its sparkle and brightness.

06

Carat weight and size

One carat equals 0.2 g. Compare transparent gems by price per carat rather than total price. Because large fine stones are rarer, the per-carat price usually rises with size, so a single 1 ct stone is worth far more than several small stones totaling 1 ct (marked 'ct TW'). Weight and apparent size differ: a low-density gem such as emerald looks larger than a ruby of the same weight, and proportions change the face-up size. Opaque and translucent materials and small calibrated stones are often sold per piece or by millimeter size.

07

Stars, cat's-eyes and optical effects

Phenomenal stones are cut as cabochons to display an effect. A cat's-eye should show a single sharp, straight, centered band crossing the dome; a star should have distinct, straight, centered rays reaching the edge, best seen under a single point light. Natural stars are rarely perfect, and a very sharp star combined with intense color may point to a synthetic. Higher transparency and a purer body color increase value.

08

Treatments and disclosure

Many gems are treated to improve color or clarity: heating (routine for ruby, sapphire, aquamarine and tanzanite), irradiation (blue topaz), oil or resin filling (emerald), dyeing, waxing, impregnation, glass filling and surface diffusion. Stable, accepted treatments such as heating barely change prices for commercial qualities, but fine untreated stones with a lab report earn a premium, while diffusion, glass filling and dye lower value sharply. Sellers should disclose treatments and explain care: ask, have the answer written on the receipt, and get a lab report for expensive stones.

09

Synthetics, imitations and composites

A synthetic has the same chemistry and properties as the natural gem but is grown in a lab (ruby, sapphire, emerald, alexandrite, spinel, quartz, opal and others); it costs far less and does not hold its value like a natural stone. An imitation only looks similar: glass, cubic zirconia, or a garnet sold as ruby. Doublets and triplets join several pieces, sometimes natural material with synthetic. Watch for misleading names such as 'Cape ruby' or 'Japanese amethyst', and for closed-back settings that can hide foil or paint.

10

Origin

Some origins carry prestige and a premium when confirmed by a respected lab: Kashmir, Burma (Myanmar) and Sri Lanka for sapphire, Burma for ruby, Colombia for emerald, Russia for demantoid and alexandrite, Iran for turquoise and Afghanistan for lapis lazuli. Origin alone never guarantees quality, and fine stones come from many localities. Judge the stone itself first and treat origin as a secondary factor that must be documented.

11

Durability and care

Hardness (scratch resistance), toughness (resistance to chipping and breaking) and cleavage determine how well a gem wears. Many colored stones dislike sudden temperature changes, and some are harmed by heat, solvents or ultrasonic cleaners — notably emerald, opal, tanzanite, topaz, turquoise, malachite and lapis lazuli. The safest cleaning is lukewarm water, mild soap and a soft cloth. Very thin girdles, overly shallow cuts and large cracks also reduce durability, and therefore value.

02 / By gemstone

Emerald

Species
Beryl
Hardness (Mohs)
7.5–8
    • Color comes first: the most prized emeralds are a saturated, pure green to slightly bluish green in a medium to medium-dark tone. Very light material is often sold as 'green beryl' and is worth a small fraction of a deep green stone.
    • Grayish, brownish or yellowish tints lower value, as do pale, washed-out centers. Check that the stone keeps its color away from direct light, not only under a spotlight.
    • Inclusions are normal — the trade calls them the 'jardin' (garden) — so emerald is judged more leniently than other gems. Even so, the fewer and less visible the inclusions, the higher the price.
    • Transparency is decisive: a transparent emerald can be worth several times more than a translucent one of the same color. Cloudy or 'sleepy' stones lack life.
    • Surface-reaching fractures, especially on the table, hurt both beauty and durability. Examine the stone from top, sides and bottom with a 10x loupe.
    • Emeralds are usually step-cut (the 'emerald cut'), which protects the corners. Because rough is costly, cutters often keep weight at the expense of brilliance, so windows and asymmetry are common; a well-proportioned, lively stone deserves a premium.
    • Despite a hardness of 7.5–8, emerald is brittle because of its fractures: avoid knocks, heat, sudden temperature changes, solvents and ultrasonic or steam cleaning.
    • Emerald has a low density, so a 1 ct emerald looks noticeably larger than a 1 ct ruby or sapphire.
    • Colombia is the leading source of top-grade emerald; Zambia, Zimbabwe, Brazil and Pakistan also produce fine stones. A prestigious origin only adds value when a respected lab confirms it.
    • Lab-grown emeralds are common and far cheaper. Green glass, green cubic zirconia, plastic-coated beryl and 'soudé' triplets (pale beryl glued with green cement) are used as imitations.
Treatments

Nearly all emeralds are fracture-filled to hide surface-reaching cracks and improve transparency. Oil is the traditional, accepted treatment (cedarwood oil is considered more stable than palm oil) and can be cleaned out and redone; epoxy-type resins are harder or impossible to remove and are less favored in expensive stones; green-tinted oil or dye is not acceptable. Fillers may dry out or discolor over time. Treatment must be disclosed, and only a gem lab can judge the type and extent of filling.

Buying tips
  • → Ask what the stone was filled with and to what degree, and have the disclosure written on the receipt.
  • → For an important purchase, get a lab report stating the level of clarity enhancement and, if claimed, the origin.
  • → Compare emeralds only with other emeralds, never with naturally cleaner gems such as aquamarine.
  • → Clean with lukewarm soapy water only; never use ultrasonic or steam cleaners, alcohol or acetone.
  • → For daily-wear rings, choose protective settings (bezel or guarded corners); a reputable jeweler can re-oil a stone whose filling has dried out.

Ruby

Species
Corundum
Hardness (Mohs)
9
    • Top color is a pure, strong red in a medium to medium-dark tone with as little brown, gray or black as possible; dealers disagree on whether slightly purplish or slightly orangy red is better.
    • A strong red fluorescence is a plus, and fine color should look good in any lighting.
    • Inclusions are normal and often eye-visible; fewer, less visible inclusions raise value, while large surface cracks lower it.
    • Transparency largely determines a ruby's life; opaque material is very inexpensive.
    • Cutting often favors weight, so windows and lopsided profiles are common; a well-cut ruby stands out.
    • Burmese (Myanmar) origin can earn a premium with a respected lab report, but fine rubies also come from Thailand, Cambodia, Vietnam, Tanzania and Kenya.
Treatments

Heating to improve color and clarity is routine and accepted. Glass or epoxy filling of fractures, red oils or dyes, and surface diffusion strongly reduce value and must be disclosed. Unheated fine stones with a lab report command a premium. Heavily abraded facet edges on an unworn stone may signal brittleness from improper heating.

Buying tips
  • → Ask whether the ruby is heated only, or also filled with glass or resin.
  • → Beware of doublets (natural top, synthetic base) and of red garnet or spinel sold as ruby.
  • → Synthetic ruby has been sold since the early 1900s, so old family jewelry is no proof of natural origin.

Sapphire

Species
Corundum
Hardness (Mohs)
9
    • The most valued blue is pure to slightly violetish blue in a medium to medium-dark tone; greenish, grayish, pale or blackish stones cost the least.
    • Among fancy colors, padparadscha (pinkish orange) is the rarest, followed by pink; orange outranks purple and yellow, and green is usually the least expensive.
    • Sapphire should be transparent and reasonably clean; a soft, velvety haze is prized in Kashmir-type stones.
    • Look for windows and large dark areas, which are common in deep blue stones, and for visible color banding.
    • Origin prestige runs from Kashmir to Burma (Myanmar) to Sri Lanka; overly dark, low-transparency stones are among the cheapest.
    • For star sapphires, judge how visible, sharp and centered the star is and the purity of the body color; natural stars are rarely perfect.
Treatments

Heating is routine and accepted. Surface diffusion adds a thin colored layer that can be polished away; it must be disclosed and greatly lowers value. Some yellow and orange sapphires are irradiated and may fade. Fine unheated stones with a lab report earn a premium.

Buying tips
  • → Ask for a written statement of treatment, and a lab report for any stone sold as unheated or of a prestigious origin.
  • → Beware of sapphire doublets and of very perfect, intensely colored star stones, which are usually synthetic.
  • → Colorless (white) sapphire is a durable natural alternative to diamond.

Aquamarine

Species
Beryl
Hardness (Mohs)
7.5–8
    • The more intense the blue, the more valuable the stone; most aquamarine is light, so deeper blues are scarce.
    • A pure blue is preferred today over the naturally greenish blue that was favored before the 1900s.
    • Aquamarine is expected to be eye-clean and highly transparent, even under magnification; visible inclusions noticeably reduce value.
    • Material is affordable enough to be cut well, so insist on good proportions without a large window.
    • Color is normally even; obvious color zoning is a negative.
Treatments

Most aquamarine is heated to remove the green component, producing a permanent blue. This is standard and widely accepted.

Buying tips
  • → Blue topaz and blue zircon can look similar; ask for the identity on the receipt.
  • → Use caution with ultrasonic cleaning.

Morganite & other beryls

Species
Beryl
Hardness (Mohs)
7.5–8
    • Morganite (pink, peach to purplish): color intensity drives value; strongly colored stones are much rarer than the common pale pink.
    • Heliodor (yellow or golden beryl) is fairly common and affordable.
    • Red beryl (bixbite) is rare and mostly a collector's gem; it should not be called 'red emerald'.
    • Goshenite (colorless beryl) is uncommon and was once backed with foil to imitate diamond or emerald.
    • Like aquamarine, these beryls should be transparent and largely eye-clean.
Treatments

Some morganite is heated to purify its pink. Yellow beryl can be produced by irradiating colorless beryl and is stable. Deep blue 'Maxixe-type' beryl is irradiated and fades in light.

Buying tips
  • → Be wary of a deep blue beryl: if it is Maxixe-type, the color will not last.
  • → Cat's-eye beryl occurs mainly in aquamarine and morganite and is a collector's item.

Alexandrite & chrysoberyl

Species
Chrysoberyl
Hardness (Mohs)
8.5
    • The key factor is a distinct color change: green to bluish green in daylight, red to purplish red under incandescent light.
    • Color intensity comes next; most stones on the market show only grayish green and brownish purple.
    • Inclusions are typical in alexandrite; size and clarity also affect price.
    • Natural alexandrite is rare, whereas lab-grown alexandrite and color-change synthetic sapphire or spinel are common.
    • Chrysoberyl cat's-eye: honey-colored brownish yellow to greenish yellow with a sharp, centered eye is most valued; 'cat's-eye' used alone means chrysoberyl.
    • Transparent yellow, green or brown chrysoberyl is durable, usually clean and modestly priced.
Treatments

Natural alexandrite and chrysoberyl are generally not treated; the main risk is a synthetic or a color-change substitute.

Buying tips
  • → Always view the stone under both daylight-type and incandescent light.
  • → Ask for a lab report to confirm that an alexandrite is natural.

Amethyst

Species
Quartz
Hardness (Mohs)
7
    • The most valued color is an intense, deep, evenly distributed purple that flashes red under incandescent light; pale lavender is the least costly.
    • Transparent, eye-clean stones are readily available, so expect high clarity.
    • Check for color zoning visible face-up, a common flaw in amethyst.
    • Quartz is inexpensive enough to justify careful cutting; insist on good proportions and brilliance.
    • Main sources include Brazil, Uruguay, Bolivia and Zambia; ametrine (purple and yellow zones in one stone) comes from Bolivia.
Treatments

Some amethyst is heated to lighten it or to turn it into citrine or green quartz. The color can fade with heat or prolonged sun exposure. Synthetic amethyst is produced in large quantities and can be hard to tell from natural.

Buying tips
  • → Avoid heat, strong sun and sudden temperature changes.
  • → 'Oriental amethyst' is a misleading name for purple sapphire.

Citrine

Species
Quartz
Hardness (Mohs)
7
    • Yellow to orange quartz; richer, purer color is worth more, while brownish or pale stones are cheapest.
    • Should be transparent and eye-clean, as clean material is plentiful.
    • Much less expensive than topaz of similar color and quality.
    • Natural-color citrine is rare and usually pale yellow.
Treatments

Most citrine is heat-treated amethyst or smoky quartz. The resulting color is stable and the practice is accepted.

Buying tips
  • → Citrine is often sold as 'topaz', 'Madeira topaz' or 'quartz topaz'; make sure the receipt names the correct species.
  • → Avoid sudden temperature changes.

Chalcedony & agate

Species
Quartz (microcrystalline)
Hardness (Mohs)
6.5–7
    • Valued for color, pattern and translucency rather than weight; pieces are often sold individually rather than by the carat.
    • Fine blue chalcedony and bright apple-green chrysoprase are among the most prized varieties.
    • The family includes agate, onyx, carnelian, sard, jasper and bloodstone; distinctive, attractive patterns raise value.
    • Very tough and ideal for carvings, cameos and beads.
Treatments

Dyeing is common and accepted for agate and chalcedony; black onyx is simply dyed chalcedony, and almost all carnelian is heated and/or stained. Organic dyes may fade.

Buying tips
  • → Ask whether the color is natural; chemicals can attack dyed stones.
  • → 'Swiss jade' is dyed chalcedony and 'Swiss lapis' is dyed jasper.

Garnet

Species
Garnet group
Hardness (Mohs)
6.5–7.5
    • Garnet is a group of species with very different values: green tsavorite and demantoid are the most valuable, followed by fine spessartine, malaia and rhodolite, while ordinary red pyrope is very affordable.
    • Demantoid has more fire than diamond; 'horsetail' fiber inclusions are a plus and point to Russian origin.
    • Spessartine is best in orange with red overtones; rhodolite in a saturated, transparent purplish red that is not too dark; malaia in pinkish orange or red-tinged orange.
    • For pyrope, the purer the red, the higher the value.
    • Most transparent garnets are expected to be eye-clean.
    • Color-change garnets (e.g. blue-green in daylight, red under incandescent light) are rare collector stones.
Treatments

Garnets are rarely treated. Garnet-and-glass doublets were widely used in antique jewelry to imitate other gems.

Buying tips
  • → Avoid sudden temperature changes; ultrasonic cleaning is risky if liquid inclusions are present.
  • → Names such as 'Cape ruby' or 'Arizona ruby' refer to garnet.

Iolite

Species
Cordierite
Hardness (Mohs)
7–7.5
    • Violet-blue color resembling sapphire or tanzanite at a much lower price.
    • Strong pleochroism (blue-violet, colorless to yellowish, light blue): the stone must be oriented so the best blue shows face-up.
    • Overly dark or noticeably included stones sell for much less.
    • Distinct cleavage in one direction means it should be protected from hard knocks.
Treatments

Iolite is generally not treated.

Buying tips
  • → Avoid acids and sudden temperature changes; ultrasonic cleaning is risky.
  • → 'Water sapphire' is a trade nickname for iolite, not a sapphire.

Jade

Species
Jadeite / Nephrite
Hardness (Mohs)
6–7
    • Two different minerals: jadeite (rarer and more valuable, finest from Myanmar) and nephrite (more common, slightly tougher).
    • Color: an intense green in a medium to medium-dark tone ('Imperial' jade) ranks highest, followed by lavender, then red, yellow, white and black. Grayish, brownish or yellowish greens are worth less.
    • Even color is preferred, though distinct multicolor combinations (green with lavender, or 'moss-in-snow' white with green) can be valuable.
    • Transparency: semi-transparent to highly translucent jade is best and opaque jade is worth least (except for white jade, where it matters little).
    • A fine, tightly interlocked texture takes a higher polish; cracks, spots and cloudy areas sharply reduce value.
    • Smooth oval or round cabochons outrank carved pieces; for jadeite, size and thickness also matter.
Treatments

Surface waxing only ('A jade') is accepted. Bleaching followed by polymer impregnation ('B jade') and dyeing ('C jade') reduce value; B jade can discolor and weaken over time, and dyes such as those used for lavender may fade. Reliable detection requires a well-equipped lab.

Buying tips
  • → Have the treatment status written on the receipt and get expensive pieces tested by a major lab.
  • → Many 'jades' are other stones: 'Amazon jade' is amazonite, 'Australian jade' chrysoprase, 'Indian jade' aventurine quartz.

Lapis lazuli

Species
Lazurite (rock)
Hardness (Mohs)
5–5.5
    • The finest lapis has an even, deep violet-blue color, no white calcite and only a little fine pyrite.
    • White calcite patches and lighter color, common in Chilean material, lower value.
    • A high polish adds to value.
    • Afghanistan has been the classic source of the best lapis for thousands of years.
Treatments

Dyeing to deepen color and hide calcite is common and acceptable if disclosed, but dyed lapis is the least valuable; it is often waxed to seal the dye, which may otherwise rub off. Most lapis beads are dyed.

Buying tips
  • → If the seller says the color is natural, ask for it in writing.
  • → 'Swiss lapis' and 'German lapis' are dyed jasper, not lapis.
  • → Avoid acids, solvents and ultrasonic cleaning.

Malachite

Species
Malachite
Hardness (Mohs)
3.5–4
    • Valued for bold, agate-like bands in contrasting greens; it is beautiful yet inexpensive.
    • Azurmalachite, mixed with blue azurite, offers striking color contrast.
    • Very soft with perfect cleavage: best suited to pendants, earrings, beads and decorative objects rather than rings.
Treatments

Sometimes impregnated with wax or epoxy to improve the polish and hide small cracks.

Buying tips
  • → Wipe with lukewarm soapy water and rinse; never use ultrasonics.
  • → Keep away from heat, acids, ammonia and cosmetics.

Moonstone & feldspars

Species
Feldspar
Hardness (Mohs)
6–6.5
    • Value depends mainly on adularescence: a strong, floating sheen of light.
    • Near-transparent stones with a blue sheen are the most valued; milky, translucent white stones are inexpensive.
    • A well-domed, symmetrical cabochon centers the sheen.
    • Related feldspars include labradorite (flashes of blue or multicolor), sunstone (glittery or transparent orange) and amazonite (bluish green).
    • Perfect cleavage makes feldspars prone to splitting and chipping.
Treatments

Moonstone is usually untreated. 'Rainbow moonstone' is technically a transparent labradorite.

Buying tips
  • → Avoid heat and never clean with ultrasonics or steam.
  • → Prefer protective settings for rings.

Opal

Species
Opal
Hardness (Mohs)
5.5–6.5
    • Type: solid black opal is the most valuable, followed by crystal and other light opals and boulder opal; matrix opal and assembled stones are the cheapest.
    • Body color: for black and boulder opal, the darker the background seen from the top, the higher the value.
    • Brilliance of the play-of-color is among the most important factors; the best opals stay bright even away from direct light.
    • Play-of-color hue: red is rarest and most prized, then orange, green and blue (the most common).
    • Pattern: broad flashes and harlequin (mosaic-like patches) are worth more than small pinfire specks.
    • Flaws: cracks and deep crazing (a web of fine cracks) drastically reduce value, as do sand or potch spots on the face.
    • Cut: well-domed, symmetrical cabochons, often ovals, are preferred; excess weight on the back is undesirable. Light and fire opals gain value with transparency.
Treatments

Opal may be impregnated with oil, wax or plastic to improve play-of-color or hide cracks (plastic is stable; oil and wax are not). Smoke, sugar-acid or dye treatments and painted backs imitate black opal. Doublets and triplets are legitimate when disclosed. Synthetic and imitation opals also exist.

Buying tips
  • → Have the type of opal (solid, boulder, doublet, triplet) stated on the receipt; look from the side for a straight join line.
  • → Ask about a crazing guarantee.
  • → Avoid heat, sudden temperature changes and ultrasonics; do not soak doublets or triplets.

Peridot

Species
Olivine (forsterite)
Hardness (Mohs)
6.5–7
    • The purer and greener the color, with less yellow or brown, the higher the value.
    • Better clarity commands a higher price; strong double refraction makes inclusions and back facets look doubled.
    • Affordable even in high qualities.
    • Main sources today are Pakistan and Arizona; Egypt's St. John's Island is the historic source.
Treatments

Peridot is generally not treated.

Buying tips
  • → Avoid acids and jewelers' pickling solutions; rapid heating can crack it.
  • → 'Evening emerald' is a misleading name for peridot.

Kunzite & spodumene

Species
Spodumene
Hardness (Mohs)
6.5–7
    • Kunzite is pink to violet; more saturated color is rarer and worth more than the common light pink.
    • Usually eye-clean, so high clarity is expected.
    • Strong pleochroism: the cutter must orient the stone to show the deepest color face-up.
    • Perfect cleavage in two directions makes it fragile when set or knocked.
    • Hiddenite, the emerald-green variety, is very rare; paler green material is better called green spodumene.
Treatments

Some kunzite is irradiated to intensify its color. Kunzite color can fade with strong light or heat, and irradiated green spodumene fades quickly.

Buying tips
  • → Best as evening jewelry; store away from sunlight.
  • → Avoid heat and ultrasonic cleaning.

Spinel

Species
Spinel
Hardness (Mohs)
8
    • Red is the most valued color, ideally resembling fine ruby; pink, orange ('flame') and fine blue follow.
    • Typically cleaner and more brilliant than ruby, so good clarity is expected.
    • Brownish or grayish tones lower value; blue spinel is often too dark or grayish.
    • Stones over 10 carats are rare.
    • Main sources are Myanmar (Burma) and Sri Lanka, with fine material also from Tanzania and Vietnam.
Treatments

Natural spinel is generally untreated, but synthetic spinel is very common in inexpensive jewelry.

Buying tips
  • → A natural, durable alternative to ruby or pink sapphire at a fraction of the price.
  • → Make sure the stone is natural and not synthetic spinel.

Tanzanite

Species
Zoisite
Hardness (Mohs)
6–7
    • The most valued color is a deep blue with a touch of purple (some prefer an equal blue-purple mix); blue stones outrank purple ones, and light lavender is cheapest.
    • Tanzanite is expected to be eye-clean and highly transparent; visible flaws and fractures hurt both price and salability.
    • Very strong trichroism (blue, purple and a brownish or greenish third color), so cutting orientation affects the face-up color.
    • It usually looks more purplish under incandescent light.
    • Found only in Tanzania; perfect cleavage makes it vulnerable to knocks.
Treatments

Nearly all tanzanite is heated to remove brown, gray or green and intensify the blue-violet; the result is permanent and accepted.

Buying tips
  • → Compare tanzanites with each other, not with sapphires, which are naturally more included.
  • → Avoid ultrasonics, heat and sudden temperature changes; choose protective settings for rings.
  • → 'Meru sapphire' is a misnomer for tanzanite; imitations are sometimes sold as 'synthetic tanzanite'.

Topaz

Species
Topaz
Hardness (Mohs)
8
    • Strong pink to red is the most valuable topaz; the redder and more saturated, the rarer. Natural-color pink (mainly from Pakistan) is worth much more than heated pink.
    • Imperial topaz is an intense golden orange with pink or reddish overtones; stones lacking those highlights or with weak saturation are worth less.
    • Blue topaz is plentiful and inexpensive; colorless topaz is the cheapest.
    • Topaz is usually eye-clean and well cut, so high clarity and good brilliance are expected.
    • Perfect cleavage means it can split or chip if knocked; it needs care when set.
Treatments

Blue topaz is produced by irradiating then heating colorless topaz; stones from licensed facilities are safe. Most pink topaz is heated brownish-yellow topaz. Some natural brownish topaz may fade in light.

Buying tips
  • → Ask for 'topaz' on the receipt: citrine is often sold as 'Madeira topaz' or 'Spanish topaz', and 'smoky topaz' is smoky quartz.
  • → Avoid ultrasonics and sudden temperature changes.

Tourmaline

Species
Tourmaline group
Hardness (Mohs)
7–7.5
    • Paraíba tourmaline (vivid turquoise-blue to green or violet) is the rarest and most expensive.
    • Rubellite that stays red in both daylight and incandescent light is worth more than pink stones or reds that turn brownish indoors.
    • Green: an emerald-like chrome green is top; brownish, blackish or yellowish greens are cheapest.
    • Clarity expectations vary: green and blue stones should be eye-clean, while true reds are usually included.
    • Strong dichroism makes the stone very dark along one axis, so cutting orientation matters.
    • Bicolor and watermelon stones are best with distinct, saturated colors, sharp boundaries and no fractures.
Treatments

Green and blue tourmaline is often heated to lighten the color. Pink and red stones are commonly irradiated; the color is fairly stable but strong heat can fade it. Some rubellite and cat's-eye tourmaline is filled to improve clarity.

Buying tips
  • → Check red tourmaline under incandescent light before buying.
  • → Avoid sudden temperature changes; ultrasonic cleaning is risky.
  • → 'Brazilian emerald' and 'Siberian ruby' are misnomers for tourmaline.

Turquoise

Species
Turquoise
Hardness (Mohs)
5–6
    • The most valued turquoise is untreated, dense and an even, intense sky blue, classically from Iran.
    • Green or pale color and spider-web matrix lines lower value, although some buyers prefer greenish or patterned stones.
    • Porous material may change color or crumble over time.
    • Turquoise in genuine Native American or antique jewelry may be worth more than loose stones of the same quality.
Treatments

Almost all turquoise sold today is stabilized with plastic, often with added colorant, or impregnated with wax, which can pick up dirt and discolor. Imitations are common.

Buying tips
  • → Assume it is treated unless a trustworthy seller writes 'natural, untreated turquoise' on the receipt.
  • → Keep it away from perfume, cosmetics, lotions, heat and ultrasonic cleaners.

Zircon

Species
Zircon
Hardness (Mohs)
6–7.5
    • Prized for exceptional brilliance and fire; blue is the most popular color today.
    • Intense, pure colors are worth more; brownish, grayish or pale stones less.
    • Zircon is a natural gem, not the synthetic cubic zirconia.
    • Heated zircon is brittle and its facet edges abrade easily, especially in rings.
Treatments

Blue, colorless and many golden zircons are produced by heating brownish material; some heated stones may revert toward their original color.

Buying tips
  • → Store separately and prefer protective settings to avoid chipped edges.
  • → Avoid sudden temperature changes; ultrasonic cleaning is risky.

Factual reference: Renée Newman, Gemstone Buying Guide (International Jewelry Publications). Summarised in EMR's own words.